The man he killed poem annotated. The Man He Killed Quotes 2022-11-19
The man he killed poem annotated
"The Man He Killed" is a poem written by Thomas Hardy in 1902. It tells the story of a soldier who reflects on the fact that he killed a man in a war and how, under different circumstances, they might have been friends. The poem is written in the first person perspective, with the soldier speaking directly to the reader.
The first stanza introduces the soldier and sets the scene of the battlefield. The soldier describes how he killed a man, and then reflects on how the man looked and how he himself looked at the time. The soldier notes that the man he killed was "just as alive" as he was, and that the only difference between them was that the soldier was wearing a uniform and the man he killed was not.
The second stanza further develops the theme of the poem, as the soldier imagines what might have been if they had met under different circumstances. He speculates that they might have been friends, and that they might have had a drink together. The soldier also wonders what the man he killed might have been like, and if he had a family who would mourn his loss.
The third stanza is a turning point in the poem, as the soldier begins to feel remorse for what he has done. He recognizes that the man he killed was not his enemy, but rather someone who was "just as doomed" as he was to fight in the war. The soldier realizes that the only thing that separated them was the accident of birth, and that they were both pawns in a larger game.
The final stanza brings the poem to a close, as the soldier concludes that he is no different from the man he killed. He states that he could have been the one who was killed, and that the man he killed could have been the one standing in his place. The soldier laments the tragedy of war and the fact that it can turn friends into enemies and enemies into friends.
Overall, "The Man He Killed" is a powerful and thought-provoking poem that highlights the tragedy of war and the arbitrary nature of human conflict. It serves as a poignant reminder that, in the end, we are all human and that our differences are often superficial.
Literary Analysis of "The Man He Killed" by T. Hardy
Perhaps he had seen others join and enrolled. The persona has killed another human being and as much as he tries to blame it on the war, his guilt is eating him up. Koya University Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, vol. They are either from working class or out of work so they feel compelled to enlist in the army. I shot him dead because — Because he was my foe, Just so: my foe of course he was; That's clear enough; although The Man He Killed was written in 1902 at the time of the Second Boer War, fought between the British and the Dutch settlers in South Africa.
Further, the delivery of this theme is seen in the way a normal friendly individual is transformed into a killer. This coincides with the description of stanza two where the speaker and the foe are fighting face to face. Answer: The narrator is uncomfortable with what he has done because he tries to reason with himself, to convince himself that he had done the right thing in shooting the man. The two soldiers had similarities and therefore may have even been better friends if not brothers. They did what they were told to do. Question 14: What feeling does this poem arouse in you about war and why? The two were pitted against each other in the battlefront. The tone is somber since meeting in a bar would have allowed the speaker to have a nice moment but it is obvious, they encountered each other in a different setting.
The Man He Killed, Thomas Hardy Poem Analysis/Annotations
The poet is trying to posit that people are generally friendly but war drives them into viewing each other as enemies and end up killing each other. Had he and I but met By some old ancient inn, We should have sat us down to wet Right many a nipperkin! The poet did not believe in the Victorian faith in benevolent God. By using this stanza, the persona is drawing similarities between the two of them, but the war has turned them into enemies and killers. Had the two met at an inn, they would have had drinks together nipperkin , but they, unfortunately, met on the battlefield where one had to kill or be killed. The first stanza is a dramatic monologue combined with imagery. So, there are two aspects of the speaker's personality.
The Man He Killed Poem Summary and Analysis
Like the speaker in the poem, many people cannot think of a valid reason why they maim, injure or kill each other and destroy property in a normal situation. The poet notes that things would have been different had they met at a bar, and the contrast between a bar and the war field extends on this futility. The event has changed him. Conclusion Hardy was a talented poet who integrated traditional style with a blend of his unique structure to create informative and entertaining literature. But ranged as infantry, And staring face to face, I shot at him as he at me, And killed him in his place.
The Man He Killed Poem Summary, Notes And Line By Line Analysis In English By Thomas Hardy • English Summary
Works Cited Abdulsalm, Hamid B. When the speaker repeaatedly reminds himself of why he killed line 9-11 he proves both of these feelings. Answer: The poem is an anti-war poem. For this paper, direct quotes and paraphrased contents are used to analyze the central message and tone of the poem. Question 9: What is the message of the poem? The tone is conclusive as the narrator surmises the oddness of war. They had faced each other on the battlefield and were firing at each other. It may have been caused by his inability to understand war, the killing he committed, the futility of life, and so on.
The Man He Killed: Analysis, Tone & Summary
Hardy 1-4 The stanza above opens the poem and the reader immediately realizes that there are different settings to the story being told; one at a bar, and the other that the poet is yet to introduce. Question 15: What do the two men — the man who killed and the man who was killed have in common? It was only by chance that the narrator walked away after surviving, and the other man died. As a result, the empathy and interest of the audience are aroused since they are involved in the conversation. We should have sat us down to wet Right many a nipperkin! This is shown in how fluent he speaks when he is not speaking about the event. Question: how did he feel? The other significant aspect of the war is that the guerrilla tactic was utilized where people would be ambushed and open gunshots started Chan par. Both poems explore the impact on individuals. This emphasises the evils of war.
The Man He Killed Questions & Answers
And in the final stanza he regains the fluency he shows in the first two stanzas. I shot at him as he at me, There was a mutuality, almost an agreement, to their respective shooting as both men shot at once. It brings out the futility of the war because in the poem, the soldier shoots down another soldier with whom he had no enmity. The aim of the British was to consolidate its Empire — and of course to exploit the mineral wealth of South Africa. The two settings and their different outcomes are therefore intended to exacerbate the futility of war and how lives are lost when peace would have been better.
The Man He Killed Quotes
Throughout the poem, quotation marks are used to connotate the use of direct speech and give the impression that the person is talking directly to the reader. Answer: They two men were not enemies. Context: This poem, in the form of a monologue spoken by an infantryman, is a meditation on war, which makes a virtue of murdering men one does not even know, merely because their nation is a declared enemy of one's own. The poem by Hardy has five stanzas, each with four lines that tell the story of two soldiers who had fought in the war and killed each other just because they were enemies. The language, setting, and theme of the poem are directed towards the depiction of the futility of war. It had just seemed like a good thing at that time — patriotic, duty towards motherland, etc.