Pros and cons of sparta. Pros And Cons Of Sparta 2022-11-08
Pros and cons of sparta Rating:
Sparta was a city-state in ancient Greece that is known for its strict social and political system, as well as its formidable military. While the Sparta system had some advantages, it also had several drawbacks that had significant impacts on its citizens and on the broader ancient Greek world.
One of the main advantages of the Sparta system was its military strength. The Sparta system placed a strong emphasis on military training and discipline, and as a result, the city-state was able to field one of the most formidable armies in the ancient Greek world. This military strength allowed Sparta to expand its territory and influence, and also served as a deterrent against other city-states or foreign powers that might have considered attacking Sparta.
Another advantage of the Sparta system was its social and political stability. The strict social hierarchy in Sparta, with its emphasis on discipline and obedience, helped to maintain order and stability within the city-state. Additionally, Sparta had a unique political system that was characterized by a strong central government and a lack of democracy, which some argue helped to prevent the kind of factionalism and internal strife that plagued other city-states in ancient Greece.
However, the Sparta system also had several significant drawbacks. One of the most notable was the lack of individual freedom and autonomy enjoyed by Sparta's citizens. The strict social hierarchy and emphasis on obedience and conformity meant that individuals had limited opportunities to make their own decisions or pursue their own interests. This lack of freedom was especially pronounced for the helots, a class of slaves that made up the majority of the population in Sparta. The helots were treated as property, and were not afforded any of the rights or freedoms enjoyed by Spartan citizens.
Another drawback of the Sparta system was its limited cultural and intellectual development. The strict focus on military training and discipline meant that there was little room for artistic or intellectual pursuits in Sparta. This lack of cultural and intellectual development meant that Sparta was not a center of innovation or progress in the ancient Greek world, and that its citizens were not exposed to the same range of ideas and cultural experiences as those living in other city-states.
In conclusion, the Sparta system had both advantages and drawbacks. While its strong military and stable social and political system provided some benefits, the lack of individual freedom and cultural and intellectual development had negative impacts on its citizens and on the broader ancient Greek world.
Both sides have presented their viewpoints clearly and factually. . That means there is an extreme lack of diversity within the ruling class and that will eventually inhibit their growth over time. It was ruled by a council of 500 members who were elected by the citizens. Geographically their locations helped keep them safe from invaders. Pros and Cons of Spartan Culture 1st- A positive facet of the Spartan Code was the thought to develop their immature beginning at a immature age. It eventually spread to other civilizations and they would start to utilize this formidable tactic.
This is the start of education in Sparta. The kings, elders, and rulers of the Spartan government knew what was best for the citizens of Sparta, and, as a consequence, created strictly regimented rules that shaped Spartan lives for the better. Why were Athens and Sparta rivals? Crime statistics point toward the fact that it's actually quite a safe city for travelers—Athens is not included on lengthy lists of the world's most dangerous cities, and a 2019 crime index from Numbeo put the Greek capital at number 130 on the list, rating it safer than cities such as Tampa, Florida and Dublin,. Even though the Spartans did not focus on education that much, they still were able to create weapons that caused them to be greatly successful. Sparta people were not open to education and they only concentrated on military strength and obedience and they didn't interact much with the outside world. They had rules and laws that everyone had to follow.
In some situations, the free market can even be restricted by the actions of the oligarchs that are in charge. There are both strengths and weaknesses within each politic. How were two city-states similar in their governmental structures and how did they differ with each other? Ancient Athens, had a much more stronger basis than ancient Sparta. Where they differed was that while the Spartans had militaristic values, Athenians were Government in ancient Athens and Sparta Statue of Leonidas, The Athenian form of electing a government was a limited pnyx. Such infrastructure was not seen in Sparta. Women were living separately from spouse during their whole lives.
They were encouraged to exercise and train so that their baby would be fit for the army. The Athenians were stronger because they had a better geography, government, cultural achievements, and I would rather live in the Athens. As you know, they started young. . Athens is the capital and the largest city of Greece. The one thing that was very similar to them were their forms of government. What are some of the strengths? The kings, elders, and rulers of the Spartan government knew what was best for the citizens of Sparta, and, as a consequence, created strictly regimented rules that shaped Spartan lives for the better.
A Close Look At The Positive And Negative Side Of Spartan Education: [Essay Example], 438 words GradesFixer
Sparta's geographical location had pros and cons, however it is undeniable that without the strategically placed location of Sparta, it wouldn't have become the military superpower that we remembered. Captives became their slaves that did all the work on the agriculture farms. It is a structure where the minority, not the majority, is able to rule. Essay On Spartan Government 1292 Words 6 Pages In this essay, I would like to answer and discuss the following questions: How did the people in Athens and Sparta obtain the right to participate in public life and make decisions affecting the community? The Spartans devoted all their time to the military, partaking in military training, hunting and war battles. They believed they produced the best literature, the best poetry, the best drama, the best schools - many other Greek city-states agreed with them. Education was compulsory for the men.
If it was believed a younger warrior had a better chance of impregnating an old warrior's wife, he would allow the young man to sleep with her. Another factor that helped Sparta geographically was that it was located near the river Evrotas. This not only ensured that all citizens were able-bodied and working to improve the city-state at all times, but improved the gene pool of the civilization by eliminating any possible genetic disorders with visible phenotypes within the society. It still allows anyone to join. The country of Persia had absolute rule.
The climate of Sparta was warm and very dry, this made the need of a river such as the Evrotas essential to its survival and success. First, the army of Sparta was the strongest fighting force in Greece. Spartans, who were outnumbered by the Helots, often treated them brutally and oppressively in an effort to prevent uprisings. However, many other things helped the Spartans become so successful, one such thing was its geography. Why living in Athens is better than Sparta? What are some pros and cons of Athenian democracy? That recognition makes it possible to resist its formation, whether it occurs in business or within the government. On the other hand, Athens did not have a very strong army, their expertise was in the navy. This idea eventually led to war between the What the two communities had in common was that they were both thinkers.
Check Out This Informative Sparta Vs. Athens Comparison Chart
This form of oligarchical government was elected by Spartan citizens who were over thirty years of age. Math and science were not even taught at all! These athletic competitions were part of their physical education. What are some advantages of Athens? The idea is this: if you study long enough and work hard enough, you have the chance to experience success. Sparta was a powerful city-state in ancient Greece. This location provided an advantage from both a defensive and agricultural standpoint. Differences — Similarities — Athens versus Sparta comparison chart Athens Sparta About The capital and largest city of Greece.
Professionals and Cons of the Spartans Essay Example
States like Sparta kept oligarchic form of government for the most of its history, while Athens changed from somewhat monarchic state what we know as democracy today. Also in a hilly area that provides natural defense. They could all be taught the same concepts, and this would create more unity among the people which was very important, although the method by which they took action upon this was somewhat controversial. The city is safe compared to many major cities in Europe and much more peaceful. . The high respect for human hygiene vindicated the thought of a respected aged category. Even when access is restricted, there is still a hope present and that helps society progress forward.